Mehrweg – the German system of reusable packaging – was not created by a single act, or in a single year. Germany has been building it since 1991: first through the Packaging Ordinance (Verpackungsverordnung), and from 2019 through the Packaging Act (*VerpackG, Verpackungsgesetz). More than three decades is time enough to make – and to correct – most of the mistakes on offer. Poland is entering the same process on a different timetable: the PPWR (Regulation (EU) 2025/40), which applies from 12 August 2026, sets the re-use targets, and the first thresholds for transport packaging take effect in 2030. A manufacturer of transport packaging working inside a group of German descent since 1985 sees something that is not visible from within the Polish market: which German solutions worked, and which turned out to be dead ends. This article gathers 5 lessons from the German system* – so that a Polish company does not have to walk the road Germany has already travelled.

Key takeaways

  • A written target is not yet a mechanism. The German Packaging Act sets the beverage market a re-use target of at least 70%; in 2023 the actual share was 34.3% (a GVM study commissioned by the Umweltbundesamt). The percentage in the act did not, on its own, force the result.
  • Everything turns on the packaging coming back. Consumer Mehrweg in beverages was stabilised only by the deposit (Pfand) that compels the return – mandatory from 1 January 2003, triggered by the safety catch in the Packaging Ordinance (the 72% threshold).
  • Closed B2B loops first. Consumer Mehrweg has still not reached its target, yet the transport B2B loop (crates, containers, pallets) has become a durable foundation. The PPWR takes the same road, though it names it differently: from 1 January 2030, transport packaging circulating between the sites of one company, with linked and partner enterprises, and in supplies to another economic operator in the same Member State is to be fit for re-use within a re-use system (Article 29(2) and (3)). At this point the provision says nothing about the loop being closed – that is only one of the two permitted variants of such a system.
  • Standardisation and shared pools beat fragmentation. A shared, repeatable format closed the economics of re-use; loops built by each participant on its own did not.
  • The cost comes up front, the benefit spreads across cycles. Germany learned over more than three decades by trial and error. Poland has only until 2030, but it can skip the dead ends the DACH region has already tested.

 

Why Germany – and what “VerpackG” really is

Germany is Europe’s longest-running proving ground for reusable packaging. Start with the names, because even the industry confuses them. The Mehrweg system began in 1991 with the Packaging Ordinance (Verpackungsverordnung, VerpackV) – the first instrument in Europe to place on those putting packaging on the market the responsibility for taking it back and managing it (and which, along the way, set up the “dual system” of collection). The act cited today as “VerpackG” is the statute of 2019 (Verpackungsgesetz) – successor to the ordinance of 1991, which raised recycling rates and created a central packaging register (Zentrale Stelle Verpackungsregister). “Lessons from VerpackG” therefore means more than three decades of evolution of one system, not a single date.

Why write about this as a practitioner rather than as a law firm? bekuplast is a family business founded in 1985 in Lower Saxony, today one of Europe’s manufacturers of reusable transport packaging (RTP), with production plants in Germany and in Łaziska Górne in Poland. As a group we were on the market before Mehrweg became law, and we watched at close quarters every turn in German packaging policy: the ordinance of 1991, the deposit of 2003, the act of 2019 and the obligation to offer reusable packaging in food service from 2023. The local competition in Poland has no such market memory.

Henning Wilts, who heads the circular economy division at the Wuppertal Institut, captures the position well. In July 2023 he put it like this: “Yes, we cannot manage entirely without plastics, but we must reduce their consumption, strengthen re-use systems and, above all, keep more plastic in circulation” (our translation from the German; Zukunftswissen podcast, Wuppertal Institut, 11 July 2023). The German example shows how hard it is to do those three things at once. And what happens when one of them is missing.

 

Lesson 1: A written target is not yet a mechanism

Germany’s most expensive lesson is also its simplest: a percentage in an act forces nothing by itself. VerpackG sets the beverage market a target of at least 70% in reusable packaging (§ 1(3) of the act). The reality: according to research by the Gesellschaft für Verpackungsmarktforschung (GVM) commissioned by the Umweltbundesamt, that share stood at 33.5% in 2022 and 34.3% in 2023 – 35.7 percentage points below the target. One methodological caveat: since 2022, after the German deposit was extended, the share is calculated across all beverage segments, so these figures are not set directly against the older ones (71.7% in 1991, for instance) as a single line of decline. The conclusion does not change: the target has sat in the act for years, and the result is as absent as it ever was.

So what actually moved the German market? A mechanism, not a declaration. The Packaging Ordinance (in its wording of 1991, refined by the amendment of 1998) contained a conditional safety catch: if the share of reusable beverage packaging fell below 72%, single-use beverage packaging would become subject to a mandatory deposit. The share broke through that threshold on the way down for the first time in 1997 and kept sliding, and the catch did its work: a deposit (Pfand) on single-use beverage packaging has applied since 1 January 2003. It was the deposit that changed how the market behaved.

For a Polish company planning PPWR compliance the conclusion is very concrete. The PPWR also works with targets – for transport packaging, at least 40% reusable packaging within a re-use system from 1 January 2030 and an aim of 70% from 2040 (Article 29(1)), while in loops inside a company and in supplies to another economic operator in the same Member State the packaging is to be fit for re-use within such a system (paragraphs (2) and (3)). The words “within a” weigh more here than they seem to: a durable container that circulates without a re-use system – with no operator, no governance rules for the loop and no records – does not count towards the 40% threshold, even if it survives a hundred cycles. The German lesson says: do not treat these numbers as something that will “just happen”. The question has to be asked before the legislator asks it: what mechanism inside my company will make the packaging actually come back and be used again – an internal deposit, an ownership model, a service contract, a settlement with a partner? A target without such a mechanism is only a figure in a report.

 

Lesson 2: Re-use stands or falls on the packaging coming back

This follows directly from the first lesson. One number separates a working re-use system from a costly declaration: the redemption rate. Reusable packaging that does not come back is not reusable – it is expensive single-use packaging. The German beverage market showed this literally: as long as there was no deposit to close the loop, the reusable share fell steadily despite good intentions and labels; only financial pressure to return halted the slide.

In consumer trade that mechanism is the deposit. In B2B trade, where most of our customers operate, the equivalent of the deposit is reverse logistics and the ownership model: who owns the container, who answers for its return, how the loops are counted, what happens to packaging “lost” in transit. Without answers to those four questions a re-use system does not exist. Buying sturdier crates without designing the return repeats the mistake Germany spent a whole decade correcting with the deposit.

That is why, when planning re-use under the PPWR, the redemption rate has to be measured from the first pilot, not estimated after the event. The shorter and more controlled the loop, the higher the real return.

 

Lesson 3: Closed B2B loops first, then the rest

If one strategic conclusion had to be drawn from Germany’s three decades, it would run like this: re-use closes fastest and most durably where the loop is closed and controlled – that is, in trade between businesses. While consumer Mehrweg in beverages has still not reached its target, the transport B2B loop – crates, collapsible containers and pallets circulating between plants, warehouses and partners – has become a quiet, durable standard across the DACH region. The reason is prosaic: in a B2B loop you know the end points, you know the partner, the routes repeat, and the return can be enforced organisationally.

The EU legislator drew the same conclusion and wrote it into the PPWR, only in different language from the industry’s “closed loop”. The sharpest requirement, with no percentages and no phasing-in, applies precisely to controlled loops: supplies between the sites of one company and with linked and partner enterprises (Article 29(2)), and supplies to another economic operator in the same Member State (Article 29(3)). From 1 January 2030 the packaging on those routes is to be fit for re-use within a re-use system, while general transport trade works its way to the 40% threshold in paragraph (1).

Two caveats are easy to trip over here. First, nowhere does the provision demand that the loop be closed – it demands a re-use system, and such a system may operate as a closed loop or an open loop (the definitions are in Annex VI). In B2B a closed loop is the most common way of meeting the requirement, not the substance of it. Second, not every business-to-business delivery falls under paragraph (3): the recipient has to be another economic operator within the meaning of Article 3(1), point (12), and a professional end user (Article 3(1), point (23)) does not appear in that list. A delivery to such a user does not fall outside Article 29 – it returns to paragraph (1) and counts towards the 40% target. We set out the thresholds, exclusions and the numbering of Article 29 in detail in our analysis of transport packaging under the PPWR.

A practical order of work follows from this. Start with the loops that are already “short” today – inside the plant, inside the group and domestic B2B – because that is where re-use pays off fastest and where the bar stands highest from 2030. Leave dispersed chains with many recipients to a second stage; they fall under the percentage target in paragraph (1) in any case. Germany arrived at this after years; in Poland the order can be adopted from the outset.

 

Lesson 4: Standardisation and shared pools instead of fragmentation

This lesson is not governed by legislation – it is settled by arithmetic. The German market showed a clear pattern: re-use pays where the format is shared and repeatable, and falters where each participant builds its own incompatible loop. A shared, standardised pool of packaging raises utilisation, simplifies reverse logistics and lowers the cost of a single loop. Fragmentation produces empty runs and capital frozen in packaging that sits still instead of circulating.

One hard parameter settles it: durability counted in cycles. Industry data indicate that reusable transport packaging achieves up to 120 re-use cycles over a service life of some 7–12 years (for RPC-type crates) – per Reusable Packaging Europe, factsheet 2022. A standard, poolable format makes it easier to actually clock up those cycles: such packaging fits many routes and many partners, not one.

Tied to this is a modelling decision: your own pool or a pooling operator. For some companies pooling is cheaper (the operator supplies, washes and rotates the equipment); for others, given sufficient scale and repeatable routes, an in-house loop wins. We model that choice on scenarios in a separate article on pallet pooling. To be clear: pooling is market context and an option for the customer, not a service we are selling here – bekuplast is not a pooling operator.

 

Lesson 5: The cost comes up front, the benefit spreads across cycles

The last lesson is about time and money. Moving to reusable packaging is an investment whose cost is incurred up front (equipment, washing, reverse logistics, records) and which pays back only across repeated cycles. The “buy once and for all” myth needs defusing straight away: RTP wears out. The figures from Lesson 4 – up to 120 cycles and 7–12 years – also mark the moment at which the fleet has to be replaced, so replacing worn packaging is a real, recurring cost, not a one-off purchase. That is why the point at which re-use becomes cheaper than single-use is directional (break-even depends on rotation, the redemption rate and the routes) – we do not offer a payback “in X months” or a fixed saving in złoty as a thesis. We set out the methodology for that calculation in the article on the RTP TCO calculator.

Germany could spread this learning over more than three decades and many corrections, including the most recent ones, such as the obligation to offer reusable packaging for takeaway food and drink (from 1 January 2023, §§ 33–34 VerpackG). The smallest outlets (up to 80 m² of sales area and no more than 5 staff) were not exempted from that duty – they may only meet it in a simpler way, by filling packaging brought in by the customer. Even so cautiously designed an exception reveals a sixth, hidden truth: every derogation creates a gap and slows the spread of the system.

Poland is not given thirty-five years for trial and error – it is given the PPWR timetable with its threshold of 2030. That sounds like the weaker position, but it has another side: the dead ends the DACH region walked into can be skipped, and the formats, designs and loop models proven over three decades of German practice can be reached for at once. A company that starts building its re-use loop early – measures returns, picks a standard format, designs the reverse logistics – will meet the threshold of 2030 with a working system rather than a presentation. A company that waits “until the rules settle” will bear the same cost later, and under time pressure.

 

What this means for a Polish company

The five lessons add up to one simple order of work, the reverse of the one intuition suggests (“the rules first, then the rest”):

  1. Start with the mechanism, not the target. Before you count your re-use percentage, design what will make the packaging come back: the ownership model, the reverse logistics, the rules for settling with a partner.
  2. Measure the return from the first pilot. The redemption rate is the number that decides both the economics and compliance – do not leave it to the end.
  3. Closed B2B loops first. That is where re-use pays off fastest and where the PPWR sets the bar highest: from 2030, packaging in loops inside a company and in supplies to another economic operator in the same Member State is to be fit for re-use within a re-use system.
  4. Choose a standard, poolable format. Durability counts in cycles; a standard makes them easier to clock up.
  5. Count it as an investment spread across cycles – and start early. The cost comes up front, and your sums should treat replacing the worn fleet as a recurring cost; the point at which re-use becomes cheaper than single-use is directional and depends on your own process (methodology: the article on the RTP TCO calculator). The advantage belongs to those who enter 2030 with a working system.

If you would first like to check where your company stands today, start with the PPWR knowledge hub and readiness audit. For the context of the Polish implementing act, turn to the status of the UC100 project – UC100 is the Polish draft act implementing the PPWR – and if you work in manufacturing, we have gathered the practical uses of returnable packaging on the page for industrial production.

 

FAQ

What is Mehrweg, and how does it differ from VerpackG?

Mehrweg is the German system of reusable packaging, built since 1991. It was set in motion by the Verpackungsverordnung ordinance (1991), and the Verpackungsgesetz (VerpackG, 2019) is its present legal basis. “Mehrweg” is the system; “VerpackG” is the act in force that regulates it.

Has the German Mehrweg system been a success?

Partly. In transport B2B trade re-use has become a durable standard, but in beverages Germany is still far from the statutory target of 70% – in 2023 the share was 34.3% (a GVM study for the Umweltbundesamt). Hence the lessons for Poland: what to repeat, and what not to.

What does the German experience mean for Polish companies implementing the PPWR?

That a written target is not enough on its own. What is needed is a mechanism that compels the packaging to come back, controlled B2B loops and a standard, durable format – and it is better to start building that before the threshold of 2030.

Why the B2B loop rather than the consumer one?

Because the B2B loop is controlled: known end points, repeatable routes, an enforceable return. That is why re-use pays off there fastest – and why the PPWR sets the bar highest on those routes: from 2030, packaging in loops inside a company and in supplies to another economic operator in the same Member State is to be fit for re-use within a re-use system (Article 29(2) and (3)). The provision does not require the loop itself to be closed – a re-use system may operate as a closed loop or an open loop.

What is the deposit (Pfand), and what has it to do with re-use in a company?

The deposit is a financial mechanism that compels packaging to be returned; it stabilised the German beverage market after 2003. In a company its equivalent is the ownership model and reverse logistics – these decide whether reusable packaging actually comes back.